2012 February 1 — Since the last report from the editors of the PhyloCode Companion Volume (September 9, 2011), considerable progress has been made. As of the end of January, 263 contributions have been received, each dealing with a particular name/clade combination. Of these, 8 were subsequently either rejected or withdrawn by the authors. Of the remaining 255 contributions (versus 228 in September): 218 (85%) have been reviewed by at least two external reviewers (versus 169 [74%] in September), and 81 (32%) have been accepted (versus 10 [4%] in September). The large increase in the number of accepted contributions is due in part to a change of policy. Acceptance now requires approval of only two of the three editors, whereas approval of all three editors was required previously. After the primary and one secondary editor have approved a contribution, the third editor is given two months to review it and either approve it or explain what changes are needed. If this is not done within the two-month window, the contribution is considered accepted.

Of the 218 contributions for which two external reviews have been received:

One final statistic: Of the 137 contributions that have been externally reviewed but are not yet accepted, approximately 55% are awaiting work by the authors and 45% are in the editors' court.

* Processing of the revised manuscript by the primary editor sometimes requires several exchanges of drafts before the editor is fully satisfied with the revision, so this step can take months.

** This multi-draft revision process is sometimes repeated after comments are received from the other editor(s); there are 21 contributions that are currently being revised a second time to address issues raised by the second or third editor.

Report prepared by Phil Cantino with input from Kevin de Queiroz and Jacques Gauthier.

Latest News

Election Results
ISPN 2018 election results are available.
Companion Volume: Progress Report
Philip Cantino reports on the progress of Phylonyms, the companion volume to the PhyloCode.
PhyloCode 5.0 Beta Version
A new version of the PhyloCode will be posted once the Preface and Index have been completed. A beta version is available on request.